CLASSICAL MUSIC: WHAT IT IS, WHY IT IS IMPORTANT, AND WHAT PRM* SHOULD DO
ABOUT IT.
WHAT CLASSICAL MUSIC IS
Dictionaries contain several definitions of classical music. The most
specific is music from the classical period, i.e. of Haydn and Mozart. The
general usage of the term, however, is much broader than that; some have
suggested 'art music' as a better term. For the purposes of this discussion,
however, I will use 'classical music'. As editor of The Continuo (A Classical
Music Journal) for the last 16 years, I had to decide what classical music
events to include in the calendar, and which of those to review. For a while
it seemed to me that there was no really suitable definition to guide my
choices. Then I remembered what I had heard said about church music, that
contemporary church music modelled exclusively on popular music would have
a short life span, leaving church members - as they grew older - without any
sense of music they could relate to, because popular music would continue to
change, and contemporary church music would change with it. In contrast,
traditional church music has always added new music from the secular world,
retaining that which worked and discarding that which didn't, so that all
members had at least some music they could relate to. I suggest that
classical music resembles traditional church music, because it keeps the
best of the old, and, in time, adds the best from the ever changing popular
music world, usually after popular styles have moved on. It also adds from
folk music. There are numerous examples of this process.
The first is ragtime. The best known ragtime composer, Scott Joplin, was
an African-American, and ragtime is generally considered to be part of the
African-American heritage. I remember hearing - on one of the PRM classical
music shows - a university-based concert pianist play an entire recital of
ragtime. More recently, at a Millsaps College program featuring women in
music, there was a ragtime piece composed by one of the participants. Ragtime
is seldom heard outside the classical music arena, and may be the best
example of the 'preservation function' of classical music. Another example
from the African-American heritage is the spiritual. One can hardly find a
choral concert that does not include something from this repertoire. The
pieces may be simple or complex. The Oxford University Press (probably the
ultimate source of classical choral music) has recently published a
collection of spirituals, edited by Moses Hogan, a noted African-American
choral director and composer (recently deceased). Spirituals, however,
unlike ragtime, are also heard in church music. Other examples from the
African-American heritage are jazz and blues. Some jazz is incorporated
directly, in other examples the jazz and blues styles have been used by
traditional classical music composers. One has to think no further than
George Gershwin and his 'Rhapsody in Blue'. Gospel, which has a mixed
heritage, is slowly making its way into the classical music fold. The
Mississippi Opera, for example, is including one opera - 'The Gospel at
Colonus' (based on Sophocles' play 'Oedipus at Colonus') in gospel music
style in its 2004-2005 season. So far as folk music is concerned, its use
by classical composers has a long tradition. Think Liszt, Brahms, and
Bartok. Then think Hungarian. Think Vaughn-Williams and English. Think
Aaron Copland and Appalachia. One of the most riveting musical experiences
I have had (I remember the exact location - I was driving on North Street
near High Street) was hearing for the first time the Bulgarian State Radio
Women's Chorus on PRM (William Fulton was announcing at that moment). I
pulled over and stopped until the piece was finished. I even remember the
vehicle I was driving. A final example is movie music. It is only rarely
performed live - but is often heard on PRM.
WHY CLASSICAL MUSIC IS IMPORTANT
The next question is: Why is classical music - in this expanded sense -
important? It is simply because it has become a living museum of our musical
culture. The first phase of this role - before the development of musical
notation - was human memory. Songs were learned by rote and repeated often.
This process continued in some areas right through the twentieth century.
Then, in the second phase when music could be notated, it became possible to
recreate it long after the composer died. Notation was also used to record
much folk music. In the twentieth century the invention of recording and
radio meant that now many more people than before could hear the same music
at the same time, and dead performers could also be heard. This new
development did not diminish the importance of notation, but it did reduce
our reliance on it. Elvis Presley's music could be notated, for example,
but any valid recreation of it would require access to his recordings. By
the mid 1950s, the quality of recordings and reproduction began to improve
significantly, with the advent of what was called high fidelity ('hi-fi')
and later, stereo. I remember attending a concert of the Nashville (TN)
Symphony Orchestra in that time, when, on the page opposite the one listing
the program for the concert, there was an advertisement from one of the
hi-fi shops (I don't remember which one, but that is just as well). The ad
included a statement in large type: 'Better than being there!' with an arrow
pointing to the symphony program on the opposite page. There was some truth
in the ad, because the symphony played in the Nashville War Memorial
Auditorium, which had bad - if not wretched - acoustics. The ad, however,
was not well received. At the present time, the variety of both classical
and popular music available on CDs is immense, and with the availability of
high quality headphones and speakers, and compact CD players and amplifiers,
it is possible for an individual to have access to far more music than any
one person can assimilate.
WHAT PRM SHOULD DO ABOUT CLASSICAL MUSIC - PART 1.
The final question, the role of PRM in all this, enters at this point. Some
have suggested that listeners who depend on PRM for classical music should
just use CDs. There are, however, two very important reasons that private
listening is not sufficient. First, I should explain what is known in
liturgical (and some non-liturgical) churches as the 'Lectionary'. This is a
three year schedule of scripture readings for each Sunday. It was developed
as a way to ensure that the full message of scripture - i.e. all the
important passages in both the Old Testament and New Testament - should be
covered in a three-year cycle. In classical music, the analogy is that all
styles of music (omitting the current popular styles) should be covered.
Individuals typically have favorite styles, and, left to their own devices
may never hear other styles which they might enjoy greatly. I, for example,
would never have known about the Bulgarian Radio Women's Chorus if William
Fulton had not chosen to broadcast it - I certainly would not have purchased
a tape or CD. Yet the first time I heard it I was deeply moved. The variety
of music available on PRM is impressive. Some styles deserve their own shows
- Celtic music is an example, with the program Thistle and Shamrock. Others
can be mixed in with more traditional forms. But overall PRM does a great
job in covering all these different kinds of classical music. The comments
made by the announcers are a vital part of the presentation. They are very
informative, engage the mind, and tend to promote what has been called
'attentive listening', which is more rewarding than simply having music
going in the background. Providing for this function requires professional
and experienced announcers who have a passion for classical music - in this
area PRM may well be one of the strongest stations in all of public radio.
WHAT PRM SHOULD DO ABOUT CLASSICAL MUSIC - PART 2.
The second reason has to do with the social function of music. There is a
significant scientific literature on this point. While many of us do some
private listening, we do like to talk about the music with others; and
anyone who has attended a live performance with a large and enthusiastic
audience can testify to the added pleasure that that provides. The PRM
classical music audience relates to the individual announcers, and that
provides the social component of listening pleasure. We can telephone the
announcers; and many of us do, often on Friday, the day when listener's
suggestions are played. It may be illusory, but the illusion is effective;
we feel as if the announcer is speaking directly to us. This relationship is
also strengthened during drive time.
WHAT PRM SHOULD DO ABOUT CLASSICAL MUSIC - PART 3.
I suggest that PRM, having invested a considerable effort at building this
museum function over more than a decade, has a responsibility to continue
it. If no one were listening, then it might be abandoned. But that is not
the case. There is a substantial audience that does listen. What PRM really
needs to do is to expand this audience to include people who have not
listened to classical music before. I believe that given this challenge,
the classical music staff can rise to the occasion, within the time currently
allotted to classical music. Besides, the question is not so much the total
time for classical music as it is when that time occurs. The largest
audiences for PRM are during the morning and evening week-day commutes, and
none of those times feature classical music. I am not, however, in any way
suggesting replacing such programs as Morning Edition, All Things Considered,
and Fresh Air (an excellent show and, in my view, the best of the new
programs). Keeping the public informed is also part of PRM's responsibility.
SUMMARY
In summary, classical music is a living museum of the musical heritage
of all of our people. PRM has the resources and experience that make it
the single most important agent we have for presenting and popularizing
this museum. It thus can do for our music what the Old Capitol Museum does
for other aspects of our society, and I hope it continues to build on its
already impressive accomplishments in this area. Why? I firmly believe
that the society that abandons classical music will ultimately commit
cultural suicide.
- Glenn A. Gentry
*By PRM I mean the radio side of Mississippi Public Broadcasting, MPB.
I do not use the latter term here; it is ambiguous because it includes
television, which is outside the scope of these remarks.