David Harrison at Northminster Baptist Church, June 17, 2011
Harrison opened the program with a congregational hymn, "Praise to
the Lord" (Lobe den Herren). There was a dazzling introduction,
and - happily - a wave of the left arm when the audience was to
begin to sing. The organ was played carefully, with the commas
in the text observed by pauses, an attention to detail not often
heard. There was a very effective alternative accompaniment for
the last verse. In most churches, the most important thing an
organ must do is lead/support congregational singing, and a sung
hymn - in my view - should be included in every organ recital.
That seldom happens, but I do remember a memorable example when
Craig Cramer dedicated the St. Peter's Catholic Cathedral Rieger
organ and had the audience sing "A Mighty Fortress" (Ein Feste
Burg) to great effect. Not to belabor the point, Organ Historical
Society Conventions typically have a sung hymn at each recital,
to show how each organ handles this important function.
The remainder of the program consisted of three major organ works,
all from memory, and all requiring and receiving an uncommon
virtuosity from Harrison. In the vernacular, he has technique to
burn. The first, among Bach's best, the Toccata and Fugue in F,
was given a riveting performance. The Toccata, especially, is a
very optimistic piece. One of the technical aspects is in the
form: it begins with a manual duet over a pedal drone followed
by a solo pedal cadenza; this sequence (varied) is repeated. The main
theme is next, followed by a wicked trio. This sequence is repeated
three times (with modifications), with the three lines in the trio
rotated between hands and feet among the three versions. Then there
is a concluding section. As is customary, Harrison played the second
main division (main theme plus trio) without manual or pedal changes,
which does not allow the contrast needed to make the trios stand out.
An appealing alternative, occasionally used by some recitalists,
has the hands shifting to a contrasting manual for the trios.
This is, however, very tricky, and not practical on all organs,
because in most cases the pedal must be reduced as the trio begins
and restored as it ends, almost impossible without an assistant
to pull stops. Harrison's performance of the Toccata, however,
with some appropriate rubato in the concluding section, was so
dramatic that it brought an almost involuntary round of applause
between the Toccata and the Fugue.
The next piece, among Widor's finest, was the Allegro (1st
Movement) of the 6th Organ Symphony. It contains one of the
more difficult passages in the organ literature, an extended
trio with a 2 against 3 against 4 rhythm (the pedal playing
the 4, and the usually less reliable left hand the 3) which
Harrison sailed through with ease. At the end of this piece
there was a standing ovation. Standing ovations are fairly common
in Jackson, but only at the end of concerts. They are
rare when they occur in the middle of a program; the last one
I recall was in Paul Lee's recital at St. James' Episcopal
Church during the 2001 AGO Regional Convention. Harrison
deserved and got one here.
Shifting gears from Baroque to Romantic to Contemporary,
Harrison closed with another monumental piece, Petr Eben's
Moto Ostinato from his Sunday Music. Eben (1929-2007), a Czech,
is emerging as one of the most significant composers of the
late 20th century. While contemporary in style, his music
is nevertheless quite accessible. Though he was Catholic, his
father was a Jew and this led to Eben's internment in the
Nazi concentration camp at Buchenwald, from 1943-1945. I suspect
this may have influenced his music (as WW II may have helped
produce Duruflé's, Requiem, a masterpiece). In any case the
Moto Ostinato is a great piece, with a powerful and sometimes
intricate use of the pedals, which Harrison managed handily.
Harrison has all the marks of a rising star in the organ
world - he has technique, he has energy, and, from the
expression on his face, he loves what he is doing. Next
Saturday he will be representing the Jackson Chapter by
playing in the AGO Regional Competition for Young Organists
in High Point, NC, and, we hope, will go on to the next level.
- Glenn A. Gentry
To read more about David Harrison, Click Here